Difference between revisions of "Xara X"

From Inkscape Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Add Other Software Category)
 
(22 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
= Features in Common =
 
= Features in Common =
*In brief: both are multi-platform and are protected by the GPL. Inkscape is free software; so is [http://xaraxtreme.org/ Xara Xtreme] (currently only partially, as the renderer part of Xara is still closed and binary-only).
+
*In brief: both are multi-platform and are protected by the GPL. Inkscape is free software; so is part of [http://xaraxtreme.org/ Xara Xtreme] 3 (the renderer part of Xara is still closed and binary-only) but not 4.
  
 
= Inkscape Advantages =  
 
= Inkscape Advantages =  
  
 
=== Fundamental ===
 
=== Fundamental ===
 +
* completely free and open source (Xara Ltd. refuses to open-source its renderer library)
 
* open, text-based, XML-based standardized format (the [http://www.xara.com/support/docs/webformat/spec/ Xar File Format] is a published standard too, but not XML, and not widely adopted)
 
* open, text-based, XML-based standardized format (the [http://www.xara.com/support/docs/webformat/spec/ Xar File Format] is a published standard too, but not XML, and not widely adopted)
* scriptable (rich command line), extendable (perl/python extensions)
+
* scriptable (rich command line)
 +
* extendable (perl/python extensions)
 +
* more localisations
 +
* ports for OSX and other Unixes, apart from Windows and Linux; all ports have the same functionality (Xara's Linux port is stagnating, only Windows version is being developed)
  
 
=== Features ===
 
=== Features ===
 +
* smoother and more powerful bitmap tracer
 
* live XML tree editor
 
* live XML tree editor
 
* gaussian blur (not the same as feathering; blurs everything, can be squeezed and rotated)
 
* gaussian blur (not the same as feathering; blurs everything, can be squeezed and rotated)
 +
* other generic filters (turbulence, composite, displacement map, etc), ability to compose filter stacks
 
* live clones (copies that are linked to the original and update when it's changed)
 
* live clones (copies that are linked to the original and update when it's changed)
 
* clone tiler (can be used for two-dimensional object scattering with randomization and coloring)
 
* clone tiler (can be used for two-dimensional object scattering with randomization and coloring)
Line 17: Line 23:
 
* randomizing object positions
 
* randomizing object positions
 
* paint bucket tool to fill any bounded area with a path  
 
* paint bucket tool to fill any bounded area with a path  
* 3D box tool
+
* 3D box tool [not the same as Extrude that gives photorealistic rendering of individual objects; rather, this is a building block of coordinated 3D scenes]
 +
* eraser tool
 
* tweak tool to push, inset, outset, roughen paths and to paint/jitter colors
 
* tweak tool to push, inset, outset, roughen paths and to paint/jitter colors
* live path effects  
+
* live path effects (pattern on path, sketch, various deformations, geometric constructions), stackable and applicable to groups
* OCAL integration [Xara can download stuff from its own site only]
+
* Spiro splines (more convenient than Beziers)
* touch selection
+
* [http://www.openclipart.org/ Open Clip Art Library (OCAL)] integration [Xara can download stuff from its own site only]
 
* baseline snapping, alignment, distribution
 
* baseline snapping, alignment, distribution
 
* find dialog (find any object by type, style, id, etc)
 
* find dialog (find any object by type, style, id, etc)
* export and conversion from command line, including batch export with GUI and commandline [Xara has batch export via GUI only, using Names gallery]
 
 
* persistent per-object export hints (filename, resolution)
 
* persistent per-object export hints (filename, resolution)
 +
* export and conversions from command line, including batch export with GUI and commandline [Xara has batch export via GUI only, using Names gallery]
 
* command line query options to examine objects in a drawing
 
* command line query options to examine objects in a drawing
 
* command line access to verbs (commands) to automate tasks
 
* command line access to verbs (commands) to automate tasks
 
* hierarchical layers, "enter group" command making it a temporary layer
 
* hierarchical layers, "enter group" command making it a temporary layer
* pattern fills from arbitrary objects
+
* pattern fills from arbitrary objects; stock vector patterns
 
* gradients/patterns on stroke as well as fill
 
* gradients/patterns on stroke as well as fill
 +
* gradient handles can be multiple-selected, selected by marquee, Alt+dragged to smoothly shape, copy/paste styled; gradient can be simplified to remove extra handles
 
* transform/not transform switch for patterns and gradients
 
* transform/not transform switch for patterns and gradients
 
* switch to preserve rounded rect corners in transforms
 
* switch to preserve rounded rect corners in transforms
Line 52: Line 60:
 
* one-command removal of kerns from text
 
* one-command removal of kerns from text
 
* rotating characters in text (including text on path)
 
* rotating characters in text (including text on path)
* whiteboard (interactive collaborative drawing across the net)
 
 
* connector tool for diagrams
 
* connector tool for diagrams
 
* automatic diagram layout  
 
* automatic diagram layout  
 
* removing overlaps
 
* removing overlaps
* extension effects for paths: randomize, add nodes, swirl, fractal, function plotter and many others
+
* extensions for paths: randomize, add nodes, swirl, fractal, function plotter and many others
* extension effects for colors (inverse, more saturation, replace etc) and text (sentence case, randomize case, replace etc)
+
* extensions for colors (inverse, more saturation, replace etc) and text (sentence case, randomize case, replace etc)
* smoother and more powerful bitmap tracer
+
* extensions for rendering barcodes, function plotter, L-systems, and many others
 
* icon preview
 
* icon preview
 
* masks separate from fill
 
* masks separate from fill
 +
* vector import of PDF and CS AI (Xara either fails or imports by rasterization)
 +
* autosave
  
 
=== convenience ===
 
=== convenience ===
 
* overall, '''times''' more keyboard shortcuts than in xara
 
* overall, '''times''' more keyboard shortcuts than in xara
* a large part of all keys are configurable (including Xara emulation option)
+
* a large part of all keys are configurable (including Xara emulation option) via an XML config file
 
* keys for canvas scrolling (with acceleration)
 
* keys for canvas scrolling (with acceleration)
 
* keys for scaling and rotating (including pixel-size)
 
* keys for scaling and rotating (including pixel-size)
Line 70: Line 79:
 
* keys for letterspacing, linespacing, kerning in text (including pixel-size)
 
* keys for letterspacing, linespacing, kerning in text (including pixel-size)
 
* nodes can be moved with snapping along the adjacent straight line segments or their Bezier controls
 
* nodes can be moved with snapping along the adjacent straight line segments or their Bezier controls
 +
* more snapping options, on-canvas snapping indicator
 
* gradient handles can merge and unmerge
 
* gradient handles can merge and unmerge
 
* history of zooms (Xara has a single "previous zoom")
 
* history of zooms (Xara has a single "previous zoom")
Line 76: Line 86:
 
* "bounding box" per-object selection hints
 
* "bounding box" per-object selection hints
 
* cursor changes over selectable objects
 
* cursor changes over selectable objects
 +
* node tool optionally highlights mouseovered paths
 
* more precision in editable numeric fields
 
* more precision in editable numeric fields
  
Line 82: Line 93:
 
* fast renderer
 
* fast renderer
 
* blends [Inkscape has limited path+style blending via Interpolate extension]
 
* blends [Inkscape has limited path+style blending via Interpolate extension]
* envelopes, including curvilinear and perspective [Inkscape has non-interactive analog via Envelope and Perspective extensions; also non-perspective distortions can be made via node sculpting]
+
* envelopes, including curvilinear and perspective [Inkscape has non-interactive analog via Envelope and Perspective extensions; also non-perspective destructive distortions can be made via node sculpting or tweak tool]
 
* linked colors
 
* linked colors
 
* Pantone colors
 
* Pantone colors
 
* Photoshop plugins[[/Live]] effects
 
* Photoshop plugins[[/Live]] effects
* editing "clipview" clippath without unclipping?
 
 
* integrated Picture Editor for embedded bitmaps
 
* integrated Picture Editor for embedded bitmaps
* can node-edit more than one path at a time
+
* brushes along path can be used for object scattering with randomization [Inkscape's pattern-along-path LPE has no randomization]
* brushes along path, path remains editable [Inkscape has non-interactive analog via Pattern along Path extension], can be used for object scattering with randomization
+
* variable stroke width, with selectable profiles or taken from pressure sensitivity [Inkscape can do this via pattern-along-path LPE]
* variable stroke width, with selectable profiles or taken from pressure sensitivity  
 
* dynamic drop shadows [can be emulated in Inkscape via clones+blur]
 
 
* feathering objects' edges (not the same as blurring - only inward from edge, like a blurred transparency mask) [can be emulated in Inkscape via clone+blur+mask]
 
* feathering objects' edges (not the same as blurring - only inward from edge, like a blurred transparency mask) [can be emulated in Inkscape via clone+blur+mask]
 
* more gradient types (conic, 4-point etc) [a limitation of the SVG specification, only linear and radial are defined]
 
* more gradient types (conic, 4-point etc) [a limitation of the SVG specification, only linear and radial are defined]
* bevel tool (outer/inner; join types; size; light angle and elevation; flat/rounded/chiseled etc types (15 in total))
+
* bevel tool (outer/inner; join types; size; light angle and elevation; flat/rounded/chiseled etc types (15 in total)) [some of this can be done in Inkscape via filters]
 
* "nav bar" tool for buttons (hidden in Xtreme)
 
* "nav bar" tool for buttons (hidden in Xtreme)
 
* quick transparency gradients separate from fill [to some extent, can be emulated by SVG masks]
 
* quick transparency gradients separate from fill [to some extent, can be emulated by SVG masks]
* gradient profiles [SVG limitation, can be clumsily approximated by multistage gradients]
+
* gradient profiles [SVG limitation, in Inkscape can be approximated by multistage gradients]
 
* rainbow/alt-rainbow gradient options
 
* rainbow/alt-rainbow gradient options
 
* different star/polygon rounding (both Xara's and Inkscape's approaches have their advantages)
 
* different star/polygon rounding (both Xara's and Inkscape's approaches have their advantages)
* fractal fill (two preset types, no parameters)
+
* some input and output formats that Inkscape does not support, including Flash; but not yet SVG
* more input and output formats (including CDR, Flash; but not yet SVG)
 
 
* non-AA display mode (note: anti-aliasing is _not_ a significant factor in the speed of Inkscape)
 
* non-AA display mode (note: anti-aliasing is _not_ a significant factor in the speed of Inkscape)
 
* linked stretching (autoscaling objects), e.g. stretching button to fit the text
 
* linked stretching (autoscaling objects), e.g. stretching button to fit the text
 +
 +
==3.2 features:==
 +
* Integrates with external photo editors
 +
* MS Word copy/paste
 +
* RTF, raw photo import
 +
** RTF import can be done via GTK APIs. Raw photo import should use dcraw, or code derived from dcraw.
 +
* PDF-X export
 +
* XPS import/export
 +
** This a royalty-free XML-based PDF replacement format from Microsoft. There is FOSS support for it, i.e. in Okular for KDE4.
 +
* Multipage
 +
* Text tool: paragraph spacing, snapping to pixel grid, soft hyphens, smart quotes
 +
* PSD import/export
 +
** Would require reverse-engineering Photoshop, as there is no published specification
 +
* Flash animations
 +
* Color separations
 +
** This means producing copies of the original image, each one containing one of the channels. This should probably be postponed after the Cairo move.
 +
 +
==Version 4 features:==
 +
 +
* 3D extrude tool with 3D rotation and lighting controls
 +
* HTML export with images
 +
* text flow around shapes
 +
* text underline
 +
* optional Adobe-like rubberband selection - objects that are touched by rect
 +
* live selecting while dragging
 +
* fonts grouped into families in Font list
 +
* key shortcuts customizable
  
 
= Per-feature comparison: =
 
= Per-feature comparison: =
Line 109: Line 143:
 
== Rectangle tool: ==
 
== Rectangle tool: ==
 
Xara:
 
Xara:
* Corner radii only in relative units (% of width/height)
+
* Corner curves must be the same on each side of a corner, but then stretch if the object is resized. The curvature units aren't either percentages or pixels...?
 
* Can create with rotation ("Radius creation" and "Diameter creation" options)
 
* Can create with rotation ("Radius creation" and "Diameter creation" options)
 
* Can edit centre X/Y numerically
 
* Can edit centre X/Y numerically
Line 137: Line 171:
  
  
== Pen tool: ==
+
== Pen/shape editor tool: ==
 
Xara:
 
Xara:
* you can drag curve and nodes (with snapping and closing) while in the tool (but, strangely, not node handles)
+
* with the pen tool you can drag curve and nodes (with snapping and closing) while the tool is active but, strangely, not node handles. with the shape editor tool the handles can be moved and new points also added
 
Inkscape:
 
Inkscape:
* live preview of the next segment
+
* live preview of the next segment (exists in Xara when clicking/holding and dragging with the shape editor tool)
* you can create hor/vert straight line segments with Ctrl
+
* you can create hor/vert straight line segments with Ctrl (the same in Xara but only with the shape editor tool)
* length/angle display in statusbar
+
* length/angle display in statusbar (again, in Xara only with the shape editor tool)
 
* you can easily create disconnected subpaths (starting with Shift)
 
* you can easily create disconnected subpaths (starting with Shift)
  
Line 183: Line 217:
  
 
[http://www.talkgraphics.com/showthread.php?t=26742 Another relevant thread on Talkgraphics]
 
[http://www.talkgraphics.com/showthread.php?t=26742 Another relevant thread on Talkgraphics]
 +
 +
[http://www.talkgraphics.com/showthread.php?t=31719 Yet another relevant thread on Talkgraphics]
 +
 +
[[Category:Other Software]]

Latest revision as of 20:07, 28 December 2012

Features in Common

  • In brief: both are multi-platform and are protected by the GPL. Inkscape is free software; so is part of Xara Xtreme 3 (the renderer part of Xara is still closed and binary-only) but not 4.

Inkscape Advantages

Fundamental

  • completely free and open source (Xara Ltd. refuses to open-source its renderer library)
  • open, text-based, XML-based standardized format (the Xar File Format is a published standard too, but not XML, and not widely adopted)
  • scriptable (rich command line)
  • extendable (perl/python extensions)
  • more localisations
  • ports for OSX and other Unixes, apart from Windows and Linux; all ports have the same functionality (Xara's Linux port is stagnating, only Windows version is being developed)

Features

  • smoother and more powerful bitmap tracer
  • live XML tree editor
  • gaussian blur (not the same as feathering; blurs everything, can be squeezed and rotated)
  • other generic filters (turbulence, composite, displacement map, etc), ability to compose filter stacks
  • live clones (copies that are linked to the original and update when it's changed)
  • clone tiler (can be used for two-dimensional object scattering with randomization and coloring)
  • tile tracing (tracing anything by a pattern of clones)
  • unclumping (two-dimensional, incremental equidistant distribution of objects)
  • randomizing object positions
  • paint bucket tool to fill any bounded area with a path
  • 3D box tool [not the same as Extrude that gives photorealistic rendering of individual objects; rather, this is a building block of coordinated 3D scenes]
  • eraser tool
  • tweak tool to push, inset, outset, roughen paths and to paint/jitter colors
  • live path effects (pattern on path, sketch, various deformations, geometric constructions), stackable and applicable to groups
  • Spiro splines (more convenient than Beziers)
  • Open Clip Art Library (OCAL) integration [Xara can download stuff from its own site only]
  • baseline snapping, alignment, distribution
  • find dialog (find any object by type, style, id, etc)
  • persistent per-object export hints (filename, resolution)
  • export and conversions from command line, including batch export with GUI and commandline [Xara has batch export via GUI only, using Names gallery]
  • command line query options to examine objects in a drawing
  • command line access to verbs (commands) to automate tasks
  • hierarchical layers, "enter group" command making it a temporary layer
  • pattern fills from arbitrary objects; stock vector patterns
  • gradients/patterns on stroke as well as fill
  • gradient handles can be multiple-selected, selected by marquee, Alt+dragged to smoothly shape, copy/paste styled; gradient can be simplified to remove extra handles
  • transform/not transform switch for patterns and gradients
  • switch to preserve rounded rect corners in transforms
  • scale/rotate/skew any number of objects separately, each around its own center
  • numeric skew (both axes; by angle, %, displacement)
  • editing transform matrix
  • persistent per-object rotation centers
  • pasting of size, width, height
  • simplify-like deletion of nodes
  • node sculpting
  • symmetric nodes
  • different star/polygon rounding (both Xara's and Inkscape's approaches have their advantages)
  • randomized stars
  • spirals
  • easy segment and arc from ellipse
  • the ability to combine color and transparency in a gradient
  • linked offsets and text-on-path remain freely transformable
  • convenient calligraphy pen (sensitive to tablet pressure/tilt, speed and direction, with tremor/wiggle)
  • guided drawing, tracing background in calligraphic
  • flowing text into arbitrary shapes, chaining, exclusion
  • one-command removal of kerns from text
  • rotating characters in text (including text on path)
  • connector tool for diagrams
  • automatic diagram layout
  • removing overlaps
  • extensions for paths: randomize, add nodes, swirl, fractal, function plotter and many others
  • extensions for colors (inverse, more saturation, replace etc) and text (sentence case, randomize case, replace etc)
  • extensions for rendering barcodes, function plotter, L-systems, and many others
  • icon preview
  • masks separate from fill
  • vector import of PDF and CS AI (Xara either fails or imports by rasterization)
  • autosave

convenience

  • overall, times more keyboard shortcuts than in xara
  • a large part of all keys are configurable (including Xara emulation option) via an XML config file
  • keys for canvas scrolling (with acceleration)
  • keys for scaling and rotating (including pixel-size)
  • keys for scaling and rotating (including pixel-size) of nodes, including scale/rotate of node groups
  • keys for letterspacing, linespacing, kerning in text (including pixel-size)
  • nodes can be moved with snapping along the adjacent straight line segments or their Bezier controls
  • more snapping options, on-canvas snapping indicator
  • gradient handles can merge and unmerge
  • history of zooms (Xara has a single "previous zoom")
  • zooming by single key (+/-, without ctrl)
  • any kind of zooming (including area) without tool switching
  • "bounding box" per-object selection hints
  • cursor changes over selectable objects
  • node tool optionally highlights mouseovered paths
  • more precision in editable numeric fields

Xara advantages

  • fast renderer
  • blends [Inkscape has limited path+style blending via Interpolate extension]
  • envelopes, including curvilinear and perspective [Inkscape has non-interactive analog via Envelope and Perspective extensions; also non-perspective destructive distortions can be made via node sculpting or tweak tool]
  • linked colors
  • Pantone colors
  • Photoshop plugins/Live effects
  • integrated Picture Editor for embedded bitmaps
  • brushes along path can be used for object scattering with randomization [Inkscape's pattern-along-path LPE has no randomization]
  • variable stroke width, with selectable profiles or taken from pressure sensitivity [Inkscape can do this via pattern-along-path LPE]
  • feathering objects' edges (not the same as blurring - only inward from edge, like a blurred transparency mask) [can be emulated in Inkscape via clone+blur+mask]
  • more gradient types (conic, 4-point etc) [a limitation of the SVG specification, only linear and radial are defined]
  • bevel tool (outer/inner; join types; size; light angle and elevation; flat/rounded/chiseled etc types (15 in total)) [some of this can be done in Inkscape via filters]
  • "nav bar" tool for buttons (hidden in Xtreme)
  • quick transparency gradients separate from fill [to some extent, can be emulated by SVG masks]
  • gradient profiles [SVG limitation, in Inkscape can be approximated by multistage gradients]
  • rainbow/alt-rainbow gradient options
  • different star/polygon rounding (both Xara's and Inkscape's approaches have their advantages)
  • some input and output formats that Inkscape does not support, including Flash; but not yet SVG
  • non-AA display mode (note: anti-aliasing is _not_ a significant factor in the speed of Inkscape)
  • linked stretching (autoscaling objects), e.g. stretching button to fit the text

3.2 features:

  • Integrates with external photo editors
  • MS Word copy/paste
  • RTF, raw photo import
    • RTF import can be done via GTK APIs. Raw photo import should use dcraw, or code derived from dcraw.
  • PDF-X export
  • XPS import/export
    • This a royalty-free XML-based PDF replacement format from Microsoft. There is FOSS support for it, i.e. in Okular for KDE4.
  • Multipage
  • Text tool: paragraph spacing, snapping to pixel grid, soft hyphens, smart quotes
  • PSD import/export
    • Would require reverse-engineering Photoshop, as there is no published specification
  • Flash animations
  • Color separations
    • This means producing copies of the original image, each one containing one of the channels. This should probably be postponed after the Cairo move.

Version 4 features:

  • 3D extrude tool with 3D rotation and lighting controls
  • HTML export with images
  • text flow around shapes
  • text underline
  • optional Adobe-like rubberband selection - objects that are touched by rect
  • live selecting while dragging
  • fonts grouped into families in Font list
  • key shortcuts customizable

Per-feature comparison:

Rectangle tool:

Xara:

  • Corner curves must be the same on each side of a corner, but then stretch if the object is resized. The curvature units aren't either percentages or pixels...?
  • Can create with rotation ("Radius creation" and "Diameter creation" options)
  • Can edit centre X/Y numerically
  • Can convert to ellipse by doubleclicking center

Inkscape:

  • Preview as-you-draw
  • Corner radii only in absolute units
  • A switch to preserve corner radii in scaling

Rotation centers:

Xara:

  • BAD: looks like once you move a center of an object, ALL objects will use the same center!
  • BAD: does not survive save/reload - all objects are reset to geometric centers. (In other words, the center seems to be the property of the Selector tool, not of objects!)
  • with Ctrl, center snaps to corners/midsides

Inkscape:

  • Each object has its own center; if you want to rotate multiple objects around one center, just select them all (taking the object with the center first)
  • Centers persist through save/reload
  • Centers snap to edges and corners/midsides

Bitmap tracer:

Xara:

  • BAD: all parameters are set in some relative values in the range 1..100, except for "number of passes" which does not correspond to anything quantifiable. There's no way I could find to set explicitly the number of colors.
  • BAD: as a result, tracing a simple line art such as a two-color logo is nearly impossible. Xara almost always creates a bunch of dirt at the fringes due to antialiasing, and shapes get distorted a lot. The Monochrome option seems to be broken.
  • BAD: for photos, there's no stacking option, so full-color traces come out very untidy. The shapes are also more distorted than in Inkscape. If you try to make them less distorted, they start getting pixelated.


Pen/shape editor tool:

Xara:

  • with the pen tool you can drag curve and nodes (with snapping and closing) while the tool is active but, strangely, not node handles. with the shape editor tool the handles can be moved and new points also added

Inkscape:

  • live preview of the next segment (exists in Xara when clicking/holding and dragging with the shape editor tool)
  • you can create hor/vert straight line segments with Ctrl (the same in Xara but only with the shape editor tool)
  • length/angle display in statusbar (again, in Xara only with the shape editor tool)
  • you can easily create disconnected subpaths (starting with Shift)

Path simplification:

Xara:

  • slider for the just-drawn freehand line (only), to refit both ways (looser or tighter) while it's still selected
  • interactive 0-100% slider in Node tool, looser only but remembers setting while you have the same nodes selected lets you de-simplify back
  • works on selected nodes (actually, ONLY works on selected nodes)

Inkscape:

  • Ctrl+L works in any tool, smoothing incrementally with acceleration
  • has wider range and works more gradually
  • works on multiple objects, and on whole object without node selection

Screenshots

Screenshots on the Xara site Page mirror: Web Archive

Screenshot showing Xara Brushes

Screenshot showing Xara Clipart Gallery

Screenshot of Xara depicting a Chevrolet Automobile Screenshot of Xara Wireframe View of Chevrolet Automobile


Links

official site

community site of artists

open source Xara Xtreme

Xar File Format

Xara at Wikipedia

A relevant thread on Talkgraphics

Another relevant thread on Talkgraphics

Yet another relevant thread on Talkgraphics